The morning after the guardian went down, Richard woke before the moss had finished brightening and stared at the cave ceiling.

  The victory had felt good. Too good.

  He replayed it — the chant building, the swarm crashing over the goblin, the stick wrenched from a grown warrior's hands by a mob of half-starved pups. The look on the crowd's faces when the laughter stopped.

  Then he replayed what had happened immediately after.

  While the swarming pups had been busy stomping the guardian, the stones had scattered. And while those pups were occupied with their righteous fury, the opportunists had moved. Quick, cold-eyed pups who hadn't thrown a single punch had scooped up everything in reach and made for the warrior wall without breaking stride.

  Most who had rushed the guardian had walked away empty-handed. Bruised, panting, flushed with something that felt like victory — and hungry.

  Richard pressed his knuckles against his teeth.

  "I handed them a distraction," he thought. "And someone else ate the meal."

  He had been so focused on the statement — the defiance, the proof that the guardians could fall — that he hadn't thought past it. Which meant he'd spent political capital he didn't fully have yet, created chaos that rewarded the wrong pups, and tipped his hand to the warriors watching from the wall.

  "Not smart," he told himself. "Not smart at all."

  He filed it away. Not a mistake to repeat.

  The arena days continued, but they were no longer the only thing that structured the cave's rhythm.

  It started quietly. One morning, a group of goblins Richard had never seen before shuffled in through the cave entrance — older than the workers, moving with the unhurried ease of creatures who had stopped needing to prove anything. Their skin carried deeper hues: greens shading toward teal, golds that had gone warm and brownish with age. A few bore faded markings on their arms and necks, geometric patterns worn down to ghosts.

  They weren't workers. They carried no gourds, no ropes. Their hands were empty.

  They spread out among the pups with the calm patience of people who had done this before, and then, without preamble, they began to teach.

  It wasn't formal, exactly. One old goblin crouched near a cluster of pups, held up a stone, and said the Goblinish word for it. Waited. Said it again. Pointed at a pup, waited for the pup to attempt the syllable, then either nodded or shook her head and repeated it herself.

  Another old goblin — male, with a deep scar running from ear to jaw — played a different game. He made a face. Bared his teeth, scrunched his brow, let out a guttural noise, pointed to his stomach.

  The pups stared.

  He did it again. Then he pointed to himself, patted his stomach, and made the same noise.

  "Hungry," Richard realized, a beat before the word clicked into place in Goblinish.

  He spent the rest of that session hovering at the edge of whichever group seemed most productive, moving on when a lesson became repetitive, circling back when something new appeared. The old goblins didn't seem to mind. If anything, his obvious hunger for the material earned him an occasional approving grunt.

  The lessons came every few days after that, slotting between feedings and arena marches like something that had always been scheduled and they'd simply not been old enough for until now.

  The songs came later.

  Richard hadn't expected songs. He'd expected drills, commands, the blunt vocabulary of survival. Instead, the scar-jawed goblin sat cross-legged in the center of the cave one afternoon and began to hum.

  It was a low, rolling sound, more felt in the chest than heard. After a moment, two of the other old goblins joined in, and then the sound had shape — a melody, simple and repetitive, the kind that burrowed into the back of the mind and refused to leave.

  Then came the words.

  Richard's Goblinish was still rough, his vocabulary full of gaps, but the songs were built for young ears. Short phrases, repeated. Slow enough that even a stumbling learner could follow.

  Most were simple. A song about how to find clean water — look for where the moss grows thickest and greenest. A song about which mushrooms made you sick and which ones didn't. A counting song that also happened to encode, if you listened carefully, the basic hierarchy of who outranked whom and in which situations.

  He memorized them all.

  But one song stopped him cold.

  It wasn't sung to teach safety or food or hierarchy. The old goblins sang it differently — lower, slower, eyes half-closed. The pups around him grew still without being told to. Something in the melody said: this one matters.

  Richard pieced it together word by word, filling gaps with context, letting the repetitions do their work.

  They had come from somewhere else. Old home — that was the phrase, sung with a weight that made the cave feel smaller. A place with high mountains and forest filed with game. Cities and countries ruled by powerful goblins.

  Their god had cast them out.

  The Hungry One. The name surfaced from the melody like something dredged from deep water. A god, or something that called itself one — and the goblins had betrayed it. The song didn't say how, or what they had done. It didn't ask forgiveness. It only said that the Hungry One had looked down at them in their treachery and chosen, as an act of mercy, to let a small number survive.

  Not out of love. The song made that plain. Out of something colder. Keep some. Let them remember. Let them stay small and hungry and grateful for the mercy of being allowed to exist.

  Richard sat with that for a long time after the singing stopped.

  A god that called itself the Hungry One had exiled them into this place and called it mercy.

  He looked around at the pups. At the old goblins already moving on to a simpler song about the names for different types of stone.

  "How long have they been living like this?" he thought.

  No answer came.

  He filed that away too.

  Not all the lessons were sung.

  The scar-jawed goblin — Richard had quietly started thinking of him as Scar for lack of anything better — ran a different kind of session every few days. No words, or not many. He would pick up a stone, hold it a specific way, cock his arm back, and throw.

  The stone would skip off the far cave wall with a crack that made several pups flinch.

  Then he'd look at them, jerk his chin toward the ground, and wait.

  It took exactly one attempt for Richard to understand that form mattered. His first throw went sideways and nearly hit a pup three rows over. Scar made a noise that was probably a sigh, walked over, repositioned Richard's hand without a word, pointed at the far wall, and stepped back.

  The second throw hit close enough to earn a grunt that might have been approval.

  He worked at it. Every session, he worked at it. And between sessions, when the cave was quiet and the pups were occupied with their own roughhousing, he'd find a corner and practice the motion without a stone — the weight shift, the hip turn, the follow-through Scar's demonstrations had burned into his memory.

  Unauthorized use: this story is on Amazon without permission from the author. Report any sightings.

  The grappling lessons were rougher. Scar had a way of grabbing a willing pup, demonstrating a throw in about half a second, and then stepping back to let the pups figure out the rest among themselves. Intervention was rare and wordless — a repositioned hand, a tapped foot to show where the weight should be.

  Richard lost more of those sessions than he won. He was lighter than most of the pups Scar chose for the demonstrations, and lighter meant easier to throw. But he learned how the throws worked, which muscles they used, where the leverage actually came from. He stored the losses next to everything else.

  One afternoon, a different old goblin — broad-shouldered, wearing a faded strip of yellow cloth knotted at the wrist — gathered a group of pups and began explaining something with gestures and the patient repetition Richard had come to recognize as this is important, listen.

  She drew lines in the dirt. A circle in the center. Three lines extending from it like spokes.

  She pointed to herself. To her plain gray tunic. Worker.

  She pointed to a warrior who had stepped in to observe — his tougher hide, the bone ornaments at his throat, the short knife at his belt. Warrior.

  Then, with a slight shift in posture, something quieter, almost careful, she mimed a different kind of figure — hands shaped as if holding a staff, head tilted back, eyes closed. Shaman.

  She walked through it again. Worker. Warrior. Shaman. The three lines from the circle.

  Then she added smaller marks branching off each line. Sub-groups, Richard understood. The workers had nurses — she mimed feeding, pointed to the pups. They had the teaching elders — she gestured at herself and Scar. Same roles, different caste, distinguished by the small differences in how they dressed and what they carried.

  Richard watched her mark each branch and thought about the different hues of cloth he'd seen. The yellows and browns of the workers. The dark, rough hide of the warriors. The paler robes of the shamans, dyed with whatever pigments they could get in these caves.

  Color and ornamentation, he thought. That's the uniform. That's how you read the room.

  He'd been reading it instinctively since the bead ceremony. Now he had a framework.

  He pressed the whole map into memory.

  The pups were growing.

  It wasn't gradual anymore — or rather, it had always been gradual, but there came a point where the accumulation became obvious. They moved with purpose now. Their legs carried them at a real run instead of a controlled stumble. Their arms could throw and swing and grab with coordination.

  In the arena, the change was stark.

  Where once even getting close to a guardian's stone pile had meant eating a stick, now the pups moved in patterns — not conscious strategy, nothing Richard had explicitly taught, but the kind of emergent cunning that came from bodies and minds sharpening against the same problem day after day. They feinted. They timed. They used each other as cover without being asked to.

  More of them won.

  The food side of the warrior wall was crowded in ways it hadn't been in the early days. The cauldrons emptied faster. Richard had noticed the audience thinning — fewer warriors lounging in the upper tiers, fewer workers trading stones for bowls of stew. What had once been entertainment was becoming something more like a chore to supervise.

  The nurses stopped coming at night.

  It happened without announcement. One day they were there, the next they weren't. The three-bead pups noticed, shifted restlessly, and then adapted the way everything in these caves adapted — by accepting the new reality and moving on.

  The morning it happened, the workers came early. Not with gourds. Not with ropes, even, which was the usual signal for an arena day.

  They came with nothing. Just hands and voices, herding the pups toward the entrance.

  Richard fell in without resistance, watching everything.

  The route was different.

  He knew the arena route now — every turn memorized, every landmark cataloged. This wasn't it. The passage they took was narrower, the walls less finished. No luminescent moss patterned into decorative shapes, no painted murals, no old carvings worn smooth by generations of passing hands. The air smelled different — less inhabited, more like deep cave and old water.

  After ten minutes of walking, they emerged into a cave that was larger than the nursery but smaller than the arena. Four passages led away from it: the one they'd entered through, and three others disappearing into the dark.

  The big goblin was already there, club resting on one shoulder, watching the pups file in with the same expression he always wore — somewhere between satisfaction and boredom, the look of a creature in its native element.

  He waited until the last pup had entered.

  Then he held up a single blue stone and a single red stone, one in each hand.

  The pups had seen blue stones before. They'd bled for blue stones. The red stone was new — darker, rougher, the color of dried blood.

  "Hunt," the big goblin said.

  He said the word twice, then set both stones on the ground in front of him and pointed at them, then at the passages, then back at the stones.

  His Goblinish was slower this time, Richard noticed. More deliberate. He was measuring how much to explain versus how much to act out.

  "Blue stone — you take, start." He held the blue stone to a pup near the front, who took it with the cautious speed of someone that had learned not following orders sometimes hurt. "Red stone — hidden in the caves." He swept his arm toward the three dark passages. "Find. Bring back. Both stones. Then food."

  He picked up an imaginary bowl and made an eating gesture, brow raised in question. Then let the expression drop flat. "No stones. No food."

  Simple enough: find the red stone, keep the blue one.

  Richard looked at the pups around him. A season ago, he'd have been one of maybe three who understood the rules. Now he could see comprehension moving through the crowd in real time — faces sharpening before the goblin even finished.

  They'd grown.

  The big goblin seemed to notice it too. He ran through the explanation once more, pantomiming less than he normally would, and nodded to himself with something that might have been satisfaction.

  Then he looked out over them with that same blunt grin he used right before something went wrong.

  He raised his club and brought it down. Once. Twice. Three times, the crack of it bouncing off the cave walls and coming back from the dark passages as a flattened echo.

  Warrior goblins stepped out from the shadows at the cave's edges.

  Not many. Seven, maybe eight. But they carried the same short clubs the arena guardians used, and they had the loose, ready posture of creatures who were comfortable using them.

  The big goblin's grin widened.

  "Also," he said, and took his time with the word, rolling it around like something he was enjoying, "these hunt you. Same time."

  He let that sit for a moment.

  "They catch you — stones gone." He mimed a hand snatching something away. "You come back empty."

  He looked at the pups. At their faces, which had shifted from comprehension to something harder.

  "Not scared?" he asked, with exactly the tone of someone who expected them to be.

  The cave was quiet.

  Then he pointed at the three passages, and his voice dropped into something that wasn't quite friendly and wasn't quite a threat.

  "Begin."