Richard held the howl until his lungs burned, then let it fade into a growl.

  The cave had gone quiet. Dozens of eyes stared at him from the surrounding clusters of pups—some curious, some wary, most just confused.

  Good.

  He pointed down at the pile of stones near his feet.

  "Game," he said in Goblinish, the word rough and clumsy on his tongue.

  A few pups exchanged glances. One of them—a scrawny pup with a notched ear—took a hesitant step closer.

  Richard pointed at the stones again, then at himself.

  "Me. Guard." He swept his hand toward the watching pups. "You. Take."

  More blank stares.

  Richard sighed. Words weren't going to cut it.

  He crouched over the pile of stones, arms spread wide, and bared his teeth in what he hoped was an obvious challenge. Then he jerked his chin at the notched-ear pup and beckoned.

  The pup hesitated, looked around at the others, and seemed to decide that being first was better than being left out. He rushed forward, stubby legs pumping, hands reaching for the stones.

  Richard kicked him in the chest.

  Not hard—not like the guardians in the arena—but hard enough to send him stumbling back with a surprised yelp.

  The pup landed on his rear, blinking.

  Richard pointed at the stones again, then at the pup, then made an inviting motion. Try again.

  This time, the pup came in lower, trying to duck under Richard's reach. Richard shoved him aside with his hip, then swatted his hands away when he grabbed for the pile.

  The pup retreated, rubbing his wrist.

  Richard beckoned the next one.

  It took a while—longer than he'd hoped—but eventually the pattern clicked into place. One by one, the curious pups began testing themselves against him, diving for the stones while Richard blocked, shoved, and occasionally landed a light kick or punch.

  The blows weren't anywhere near as brutal as a guardian's stick, but they still stung. Enough to make the pups think. Enough to make them remember.

  Some succeeded. Smaller, faster pups learned to time their lunges for moments when Richard was off-balance, or to feint one way and dart the other. A few of the bigger ones simply bulled through his guard, taking the hits and grabbing stones anyway.

  Most failed.

  But they kept trying.

  By the time the pile was empty, a small crowd had gathered. Pups who had been watching from the edges now pressed closer, chattering in their garbled half-language.

  Richard collected the scattered stones and rebuilt the pile.

  This time, instead of taking his place as defender, he grabbed the largest pup who had been playing—a thick-armed brute with a greenish tinge to his skin—and shoved him toward the pile.

  "You. Guard."

  The brute looked confused for a moment, then understanding dawned. His lips peeled back in a grin.

  He planted himself over the stones like a conquering warlord.

  The next few rounds were messier. The brute hit harder than Richard had, and some of the smaller pups walked away with real bruises. But none of them complained. If anything, the added danger seemed to sharpen their focus.

  Richard watched from the sidelines, arms folded, cataloging.

  "They're learning," he thought. "Not tactics, not strategy—just instinct. But instinct is a start."

  The game spread.

  By the next day, copycat versions had sprung up in different corners of the cave. Some used the same rules Richard had established; others invented their own variations. One group played a version where the "defender" had to protect a single stone while three attackers tried to steal it. Another simply wrestled for control of a pile, no rules at all.

  Richard let them play.

  He had something else in mind.

  On the third day, when the usual midday lull settled over the cave, he gathered another pile of stones in the center and let out his signature howl.

  Heads turned. Pups drifted over, already eager.

  This time, Richard didn't choose one defender.

  He chose three.

  He picked carefully—not the biggest, but the meanest. Pups he'd seen in the roughhousing games, the ones who threw punches when shoves would do, who kept hitting after their opponent had already submitted.

  He shoved them toward the pile.

  "Guard," he said. "All."

  The three exchanged looks, then spread out around the stones, forming a loose triangle. Their grins matched.

  The attackers came in waves.

  And they were slaughtered.

  Three defenders meant three sets of fists, three pairs of eyes watching different angles. Whenever a pup tried to slip through, one of the defenders would cut them off while the others closed in.

  The beatings were vicious. Not the controlled, educational blows Richard had been dishing out, but real hits—punches to the face, kicks to the ribs, elbows driven into backs. Pups crawled away bleeding from split lips and nursing bruised arms.

  Richard watched.

  Around him, the mood shifted. What had started as eager anticipation curdled into something darker. Pups who'd been waiting for their turn hung back, growling under their breath. A few snarled at the defenders, teeth bared.

  The defenders didn't care. If anything, the hostility made them bolder. One of them—a pup with a jagged scar across his scalp—laughed as he drove his knee into a smaller pup's stomach.

  That was when it happened.

  A mid-sized pup near the front, one who'd already been knocked down twice, suddenly stopped retreating. His shoulders hunched. His breath came in short, sharp bursts. His eyes went glassy and fixed on the scarred defender.

  Then he screamed and launched himself forward.

  Not at the stones.

  This novel is published on a different platform. Support the original author by finding the official source.

  At the defender.

  The scarred pup didn't have time to react. The attacker crashed into him like a battering ram, teeth sinking into his shoulder. They went down in a tangle of limbs.

  For a heartbeat, everyone froze.

  Then the dam broke.

  Pups poured in from every direction, not diving for the stones but swarming the defenders. Fists flew. Teeth snapped. The three defenders fought back, but there were too many—a tide of small, furious bodies dragging them down through sheer weight of numbers.

  Richard stepped back, staying clear of the melee.

  The thrashing lasted maybe a minute. When it was over, the three defenders lay curled on the ground, arms wrapped around their heads, whimpering. The attackers stood over them, chests heaving, blood on their knuckles.

  Then, as if someone had flipped a switch, the tension drained away.

  One of the pups bent down, picked up a stone from the scattered pile, and trotted off with it. Another followed. Within moments, the attackers had dispersed, some clutching stones, others already drifting toward other games.

  The three defenders slowly uncurled, shot hateful glares at the retreating pups, and slunk away to lick their wounds.

  No one paid them any attention.

  Richard stared at the empty space where the pile had been with a grin on his face.

  ———

  The next arena day, Richard noticed the difference immediately.

  The pups moved faster. Not just the natural speed of growing bodies, but the sharp, decisive speed of creatures who had practiced. When the big goblin slammed his club and bellowed for the games to begin, the first wave of attackers hit the guardian line like a storm.

  More stones changed hands in the opening rush than Richard had ever seen before.

  The guardians adapted, swinging harder, but the pups where adapted too. They rolled with hits instead of taking them square. They feinted and dodged. They worked in loose packs, three or four rushing at once to overwhelm a single guardian's attention.

  By the time the chaos settled into the usual pattern of grabbing and stealing, a larger portion of the pups had already secured stones and crossed to the food side.

  Richard ate his stew slowly, watching.

  The crowd in the stands seemed... different. Less enthusiastic. A few of the warrior-types who usually bought food from the workers were turning away empty-handed, the cauldrons running dry faster than expected.

  "They didn't plan for this," Richard realized. "They set aside enough food for the winners and some for the audience. But if the pups are faster, the winners eat more, and the watchers get less."

  A thin smile crept across his face.

  It wasn't much. A small inconvenience for the goblins who'd turned his suffering into entertainment.

  But it was something.

  ———

  Back in the nursery, Richard refined his approach.

  He couldn't set up impossible games too often. If every round ended with the defenders getting swarmed, no one would volunteer to defend. The game would die, and with it, the training it provided.

  So he varied the setups. Most games stayed fair—one defender, or two at most, with reasonable odds for both sides. The pups got their practice, learned their lessons, walked away with minor bruises and sharper instincts.

  But every few days, Richard would stack the deck.

  Three defenders. Or four. He'd pick the cruelest pups he could find, the ones who would push too hard, hit too often, give the attackers a reason to hate them. Some refused, smart enough to see where it was going. Many didn't — a chance to hurt without consequence was too good to pass up.

  And when the frustration built to a boiling point, he'd be there.

  "Fight," he'd growl, low at first, then louder. "Fight. Fight."

  The first time, only a few pups picked up the chant. The second time, more joined. By the third, the word spread through the crowd like wildfire, building into a thunderous roar that drowned out everything else.

  And then the swarm.

  Every time, it was the same. The defenders would hold for a few seconds—maybe longer if they were tough—and then the tide would crash over them. Fists and teeth and claws, a dozen bodies piling on, beating them into submission.

  Afterward, the pups would scatter as if nothing had happened. The game would reset. Life would go on.

  But something had changed.

  Richard could see it in the way the pups carried themselves. The way they looked at each other. The way they looked at him.

  They were still animals, driven by hunger and fear and the brutal simplicity of survival.

  But now they knew they could fight back.

  ———

  Days passed. Arena days came and went.

  The pattern held. Each time the pups were herded into the arena, they performed a little better. More of them walked away with full bellies. Fewer of them lay broken on the stone floor when the ropes came out for the march home.

  Richard didn't fool himself into thinking he'd saved them. The weak still suffered. The strong still thrived. The game was the game.

  But the margins had shifted.

  And the audience was starting to notice.

  Richard saw it in the grumbling among the warrior-types when the cauldrons emptied early. He saw it in the way some of the workers shot suspicious glances at the pup enclosure, as if trying to figure out what had changed.

  He kept his head down and his expression blank.

  "Not yet," he told himself. "Let them wonder. Let them get used to it."

  He needed them complacent.

  Because the next step would be harder to hide.

  ———

  The day Richard decided to act started like any other.

  Ropes instead of buckets. The long march through winding tunnels. The roar of the crowd. The smell of cooking meat.

  The pups were herded into the center of the arena, bindings removed, left to mill about in the space carved out for them. The big goblin went through his usual performance—club-slamming, chest-thumping, crowd-hyping.

  Richard barely heard him.

  His eyes were already moving, sorting the pups around him into categories.

  The first group was easy to spot: the strong ones, the fast ones, the pups who won consistently. They stood near the front, muscles coiled, eyes fixed on the guardian line. They would get their stones in the opening rush, same as always.

  The second group clustered in the middle: weaker, but aggressive. Pups who threw themselves at the guardians over and over, sometimes winning, often losing. They had fire, but not enough skill or strength to guarantee success.

  The third group hung at the back: weak and meek. The ones who waited for scraps, who only moved when the chaos was thick enough to hide them. Some got lucky. Most didn't.

  Richard positioned himself at the edge of the second group.

  The big goblin finished his speech and slammed his club.

  "Begin!"

  The first wave surged.

  Richard stayed still.

  He watched the strong pups tear through the guardian line, snatching stones and sprinting for the warrior wall. He watched the thieves fan out, looking for easy targets. He watched the chaos build.

  When most of the bruisers had either eaten or were occupied fighting over prizes, Richard moved.

  He didn't head for the stones.

  He headed for the pups.

  He found what he was looking for near one of the weaker guardians—a goblin whose swings were slow and whose pile had already been picked nearly clean. Around him, a cluster of second-group pups prowled, waiting for an opening, flinching back whenever the stick came up.

  Their frustration was palpable.

  Richard slipped into the cluster, keeping his movements casual.

  Then he started to chant.

  "Fight."

  Quiet at first. Almost a whisper.

  A pup next to him glanced over, confused.

  "Fight," Richard repeated, a little louder.

  Another pup picked it up, the word tumbling out half-formed. "Figh..."

  "Fight." Richard's voice rose. "Fight."

  More voices joined. The word spread, jumping from pup to pup like sparks.

  "Fight. Fight. Fight."

  The guardian in front of them noticed something was wrong. His grin faltered. He raised his stick, but his eyes were uncertain now, flicking between the dwindling pile at his feet and the growing crowd of pups who had stopped trying to grab stones and were instead... staring at him.

  "Fight. Fight. Fight."

  The chant swelled into a roar.

  Richard saw the moment it tipped. The pups' posture shifted, shoulders squaring, hands balling into fists. Their eyes went hard. Their lips peeled back.

  They weren't thinking about food anymore.

  Richard filled his lungs.

  "FIGHT!"

  The swarm hit the guardian like a wave breaking against rock.

  For a heartbeat, the goblin held. His stick cracked down, sending two pups sprawling. He kicked a third in the chest, pivoted, swung again—

  And then there were too many.

  They came from every direction, small bodies crashing into his legs, his arms, his back. Teeth sank into his wrist. Claws raked his face. Someone—maybe several someones—grabbed his stick and wrenched it from his grip.

  The guardian went down screaming.

  The pups didn't stop.

  Fists hammered into him from every angle. Feet kicked and stomped. The guardian curled into a ball, arms wrapped around his head, but the blows kept coming, a relentless storm of small furies finally given a target.

  Richard watched for a moment, savoring the sight.

  Then he stepped forward.

  The pups parted for him without thinking, still caught up in the frenzy but recognizing, on some instinctual level, that he was different.

  Richard crouched, picked up a blue stone from the scattered pile, and straightened.

  He looked down at the guardian—a grown goblin, armed and armored, reduced to a whimpering heap by a swarm of pups.

  Richard drew back his foot and kicked him in the ribs.

  Not hard enough to do real damage. Just hard enough to make a point.

  Then he turned and walked toward the warrior wall, stone in hand.

  Behind him, the pups had already lost interest in the fallen guardian. They scattered, some snatching up stones, others drifting back into the chaos of the arena.

  The crowd in the stands had gone quiet.

  Richard didn't look up. Didn't acknowledge them.

  He reached the warrior wall, held out the stone, and waited.

  The warrior who took it stared at him for a long moment, expression unreadable. Then he stepped aside.

  Richard walked through.

  On the other side, a worker shoved a bowl into his hands.

  He sat down, back against the cave wall, and began to eat.

  The stew was the same as always—hot, greasy, oversalted. But today, it tasted better.

  Richard scraped the bowl clean and licked his fingers.

  "Today was a good day," he thought.

  In the arena behind him, the chaos continued. Pups screamed and fought and bled for their chance at food.

  But something had changed.

  The guardians swung their sticks with a little less confidence now. The warriors at the wall watched the pups with sharper eyes. Even the crowd seemed subdued, their laughter thinner, their cheers less certain.

  Richard finished his meal and closed his eyes.

  "One guardian," he thought. "One small victory."

  His lips curved into a thin smile.